Fort Washington, Manhattan. November 8 to 16, 1776.
Three weeks ago I told you to remember Fort Washington. This is why.
Start on November 8. Three British ships had just gotten past the obstructions in the Hudson. Washington wrote Greene at Fort Lee that he was "inclined to think it will not be prudent to hazard the Men & Stores at Mount Washington, but as you are on the Spot, leave it to you."
Greene answered the next day. "I cannot conceive the Garrison to be in any great danger the men can be brought off at any time." And: "Col. Magaw thinks it will take them till December expires, before they can carry it."
Washington reached Fort Lee on November 13. He did not order the men out. Greene to Henry Knox, November 17: "The Evacuation or reinforcement of Fort Washington was under consideration, but finally nothing concluded on."
November 15. Howe demanded the fort's surrender. Magaw's answer: "I am determined to defend this post to the very last extremity."
November 16. Washington crossed to the island that morning and stood on Harlem Heights. The attack began about ten. Greene wrote that "We all urged his Excellency to come off." He came off.
From Fort Lee he sent Magaw a note "directing him to hold out, and I would endeavour this Evening to bring off the Garrison." Too late. Magaw "had entered too far into a Treaty to retract."
About three o'clock the fort surrendered. Washington called it "a defence of about 4 or 5 hours only." The British prisoner return counted 2,818 Americans captured.
Three days later Washington told his brother the post "was held contrary to my Wishes & opinion." In 1779 he wrote Joseph Reed about "that warfare in my mind and hesitation which ended in the loss of the garrison."
Where's Monroe? Not on any page. His regiment crossed the Hudson on November 9 and 10. That week his brigade was moving south across New Jersey, away from the river.
November 16, 1776. 45 days to December 31.
Next Thursday: Fort Lee